USPTO Returns IPR and PGR Merits Institution to PTAB

USPTO Director John A. Squires and General Counsel John F. Duffy issued a memorandum on 10 November: from 16 November, merits-based considerations in deciding whether to institute inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) return to three-member panels of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). The Director will still first review non-merits considerations, including discretionary factors, and may deny on that basis; petitions that pass are referred to a panel, which decides institution on the merits on the Director's behalf.
The change updates the 17 October 2025 memorandum on Director institution of AIA trial proceedings, under which the Director decided institution himself; the memo says he made more than 325 institution decisions involving merits-based considerations. The new process applies to every IPR and PGR without a notice referring it for merits consideration by 16 November, and briefing procedures are unchanged. If a panel institutes, a different panel, with none of the same judges, conducts the trial.
How panels will decide
- For prior-art grounds, the petitioner must show how the prior art discloses or renders obvious each limitation of each challenged claim, identifying the specific portions relied on; pointing to an examiner's findings is not enough.
- If the petitioner fails to make the required showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims, institution is denied.
- Institution is also denied where the patent owner's preliminary response, or the panel itself, identifies a reasonable, well-supported argument that a substantial majority of the challenged claims fail the standard.
- Where the arguments on a claim are in equipoise, the petitioner has not met the reasonable likelihood (IPR) or more likely than not (PGR) standard for that claim.
The memo also gives figures: in June 2025 about 60% of petitions were discretionarily denied and about 40% referred for merits review; in September 2026 the figures were 15% and 85%.
J&C recommends that companies facing US patent assertions and planning an IPR or PGR map each challenged claim, element by element, to the prior art with pinpoint citations rather than relying on findings made during examination, and choose the challenged claims with care, since weak showings on most claims can sink the whole petition. Patent owners can focus their preliminary response on showing that most challenged claims fall short of the institution threshold.
Source: www.uspto.gov


