Skip to main content

OpenAI Loses Ontario Appeal in News Publishers' Suit

Newspapers, a gavel and a maple leaf on a courtroom bench, illustrating the Canadian news publishers' suit against OpenAI

The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI's appeal on 13 November (2026 ONCA 814), upholding the Superior Court of Justice's order of 7 November 2025 that Ontario courts have jurisdiction over the suit brought by Canadian news organisations against OpenAI, which can now proceed in Ontario. The three judges were unanimous. The ruling concerns jurisdiction only; the court made no finding on whether OpenAI infringed.

The plaintiffs, including Torstar, Postmedia, The Globe and Mail, the Canadian Press and the CBC, allege that OpenAI scraped their websites and used and reproduced their content to train the large language models behind ChatGPT, claiming breach of the Copyright Act, breach of contract (website terms of use) and unjust enrichment.

  • Presumed jurisdiction: three connecting factors were made out, namely carrying on business in Ontario, a connection between the alleged copyright breaches and Ontario, and a sufficient connection between the contract and unjust enrichment claims and Ontario; the lack of a physical presence did not prevent a finding of carrying on business.
  • Merits left aside: whether the Copyright Act reaches conduct abroad and whether it displaces the contract and unjust enrichment claims are merits questions for a motion to strike.
  • Forum: the United States is not a clearly more appropriate forum; the motion judge's finding that OpenAI filed no evidence of a conflict between a Canadian judgment and existing US law was left undisturbed.

OpenAI must pay CAD 100,000 in costs of the appeal, an amount agreed between the parties. At first instance the motion had succeeded for four other named defendants.

J&C notes that foreign AI companies with users and business in Canada may face Canadian jurisdiction even without a local office, and that compliance reviews of training data should take in the target market's copyright law and website terms of use.

Source: coadecisions.ontariocourts.ca

Need to register a copyright?

Get the latest insights by email

The content in this section is provided for general reference only and does not constitute legal advice or formal service recommendations. For any specific matter, please consider the particular facts of your case and refer to the latest laws, policies, and practices of the relevant authorities.